The tribunal said Neill “failed to satisfy us that its proposed market definition” was correct and had not argued an alternative, “so the claim fails altogether” [1]. It found the better frame was a systems market covering the console and the games bought for it over its lifetime, and said Neill had not shown that Sony was dominant in any relevant market [1]. Engadget reported that the tribunal pointed to physical games and rival consoles as alternatives for players, and to evidence of consumers’ willingness to switch consoles if game prices rose [2].
The panel, chaired by Ben Tidswell, added that even on Neill’s market definition the exclusionary and pricing abuse claims would have failed [1]. It said Neill had not shown that Sony’s margin was excessive and called its unfairness case, which compared Sony with PC stores and the fee Sony charges on physical games, “extremely weak” [1].
The result differs from the same tribunal’s ruling against Apple in Kent v Apple last year, which found the App Store’s 30% commission was an abuse of dominance, Engadget noted [2]. The tribunal will hold a hearing in the week of Dec. 14 on costs and any applications for permission to appeal [1].