Design hybrid renewable energy systems for electric vehicle charging stations at various sites in Pakistan


Results are the next thing that is received after the simulation.

The Bhera location depicts a great cost execution indicative of NPC of $15,929, low LCOE $0.0225/kWh, and operating cost of − $11,643/year as shown in Table 8. Among the four locations, Bhera exhibits the second-lowest NPC and LCOE, indicating a highly cost-effective hybrid energy solution. The negative operating cost further suggests favorable economic returns, making Bhera one of the most attractive sites for EV charging infrastructure deployment.

Table 8 Cost analysis of optimal hybrid energy at Bhera motorway.

The NPC of the Hakla Motorway EV station, as presented in Table 9, is $7,893 with a lower LCOE of Rs. $0.0214/kWh, with a relatively high cost of the system. It also records the most favorable annual operating cost of − $12,000/year. These results indicate superior economic viability and energy cost performance, making Hakla the optimal location for implementing the proposed hybrid renewable energy system.

Table 9 Cost analysis of optimal hybrid energy at Hakla motorway.

For its optimal configuration, the Karachi Northern Bypass location has an NPC of $78,214, an LCOE of $0.0286/kWh, and an annual operating cost of − $8,464/year as shown in Table 10. Karachi is seen to be the least cost-effective as it has the highest NPC and the highest LCOE of the other three locations. Although the project remains economically feasible due to its negative operating cost, its overall economic performance is inferior to that of Hakla, Bhera, and Karakoram Highway.

Table 10 Cost analysis of optimal energy at Karachi highway.

The Karakoram Highway site shows economic performance very similar to that of the Bhera Motorway. The optimal system results in an NPC of $15,951, an LCOE of $0.0225/kWh, and an annual operating cost of -$11,660/year, as shown in Table 11. These values make the Karakoram Highway the third most economical place, just after Bhera. The outcome indicates that the location is an affordable hybrid energy system for supporting the EV charging demand along this strategic transportation corridor.

Table 11 Cost Analysis of optimal hybrid energy Karakoram Highway.

The bar chart is used to depict the monthly electric bill that the HOMER grid produces, with the Total costs changing depending on the month. The individual bars are further subdivided into cost elements: energy charges, demand charges, fixed charges, and maybe minimum charges. It is interesting to note that the highest number of bills occurred in January and December, which is probably because of the use of more energy and the amount of peak demand, perhaps because of winter heating or lighting needs. On the other hand, monthly bills in mid-years, such as May to August, are relatively low, implying less load or demand in those months. HOMER Grid calculates the monthly electricity bill by simulating hourly or sub-hourly energy consumption and identifying the maximum demand in each billing cycle. The total bill for a given month is calculated using the following equation:

$$ B_{month} = { }C_{energy} + C_{demand} + C_{fixed} + C_{minimum} – R_{response} $$

(10)

In this formula, \({B}_{month}=\) Total monthly utility bill ($), \({C}_{energy}=\) Monthly energy charge (based on kWh consumed) ($), \({C}_{demand}=\) Monthly demand charge (based on peak power draw) ($), \({C}_{fixed}=\) Fixed monthly service/connection charge ($), \({C}_{minimum}=\) Minimum monthly bill charge set by the utility ($). \({R}_{response}\)=Credit or revenue from demand response participation ($).

$$ C_{energy} = E_{month} \times R_{energy} $$

(11)

where \({E}_{month}=\) Total electrical energy consumed in the month (kWh). \({R}_{energy}=\) Utility energy rate ($/kWh). The total energy consumed in a month is in kWh, and Energy is the energy rate of the utility (Rs/kWh). Demand charge based on peak demand during the billing period:

$$ C_{demand} = P_{peak} \times R_{demand} $$

(12)

where \({C}_{demand}=\) Monthly demand charge ($), \({P}_{peak}=\) Peak power demand recorded during the billing period (kW), \({R}_{demand}=\) Utility demand charge rate ($/kW). Where the highest power draws in kilowatts, and the rate per KW.

A constant monthly service charge is applied regardless of consumption, ensuring the bill does not fall below a certain threshold. If demand response programs are in place, incentives earned by reducing load during critical periods are subtracted. Where the Capital cost in year, the Replacement cost in year, the operating and maintenance cost in year, the salvage value in year, the Discount rate, and the project lifetime in year (Fig. 6).

Fig. 6
Fig. 6

Monthly electricity bill.

The monthly dispatch analysis illustrates how the availability of renewable resources affects the operation of EV charging stations. In the winter months, especially January, PV generation is limited by the reduced length of daylight periods and decreased solar radiation. This means that more electricity is used for charging in the morning or evening, while renewable energy generation is mainly in the middle of the day, from around 08:00 to 15:00. The grid purchase profile confirms the rise in grid imports outside the renewable generation window, as shown in Fig. 7.

Fig. 7
Fig. 7

For January (a) PV output. (b) Grid purchase comparison with baseline.

On the other hand, because of longer daylight hours and greater solar irradiance, July has the highest contribution from Solar Energy. During the daytime, PV generation is active from around 07:00 to 17:00, and plays a major part in meeting the charging load. Consequently, the grid purchases in this scenario are much less than the base case “just grid” scenario, which is shown in Fig. 8. This shows the significance of seasonal solar resource availability for the reduction of operating costs and better utilization of renewables.

Fig. 8
Fig. 8

For July (a) PV output. (b) Grid purchase comparison with baseline.

September is a transitional month when solar and wind resources are both used to charge, as shown in Fig. 9. During daytime hours, solar generation is important, and during early morning and evening hours, wind generation supplements this production. This complementary behavior enhances the overall renewable energy penetration level even more and hence reduces the reliance on grid electricity further. The monthly dispatch results overall show that seasonal variations in renewable resources are directly affecting the grid interaction patterns. During the summer months, this means higher renewable generation reduces the use of the grid and operating costs, while lower generation during the winter months means increased reliance on grid support. With this bidirectional grid connection, the system is able to keep the charging service running continuously even in the most extreme weather conditions and to make the best use of the use of renewable energy.

Fig. 9
Fig. 9

For September (a) PV output. (b) Grid purchase comparison with baseline

The second is system 22, which yields an average of about 1,174,050 kWh per year, and has a slightly lower CAPEX of $666,573. It also has a much shorter payback period (2.97 years) as shown in Table 12. In addition, this system saves about $866,221 over 20 years, the best of the three systems both in short-run payback and in long-run profitability.

Table 12 Solar + Wind + Grid Station.

The capital costs of System 23 are approximately $852,594, and the average energy generated is 1,036,686 kWh per year. It will pay back in about 5.67 years and have estimated lifetime savings of approximately $868,382, as shown in Table 13. Although slightly more expensive than the second system initially, it provides a balanced performance in terms of energy generation and long-term savings. This setup offers superior total savings throughout the entire lifecycle of the project compared to the first and has a good profile of returns.

Table 13 Wind + Grid Station.

Techno-economic and scientific analysis of simulation results

In this section, the results of the simulation have been analyzed technically and scientifically. The HOMER Grid optimization results show that there are economically viable EV charging stations that can be installed in all four locations using a hybrid renewable energy system. These optimal setups produced a figure of LCOE ranging from $0.0214/kWh to $0.0286/kWh, significantly lower than the current electricity tariff of industries in Pakistan. The findings validate the economic advantages of the co-location of solar PV and wind energy with controlled grid interaction via net metering schemes. The overall economic performance of Hakla Motorway (EM) was best, with an NPC of $7,893, LCOE of $0.0214/kWh, and an annual operating cost of -$12,000/year. A positive economic result is attributed to the efficient use of renewable resources and to not relying on the grid. Similar results were observed at Bhera Motorway, where an NPC of $15,929 and LCOE of $0.0225/kWh were obtained, suggesting that hybrid renewable energy systems are very apt for motorway charging applications in the central Punjab area. The NPC of the Karakoram Highway site was $15,951, and the LCOE was $0.0225/kWh. Despite the lower average wind speed of this site compared to the other sites, the system configuration was optimized to achieve competitive economic performance by maximizing the use of solar energy and also implementing a strategic approach to the interaction with the grid. The highest NPC ($78,214) and the highest LCOE ($0.0286/kWh) were obtained for the location of Karachi Northern Bypass. The good solar and wind resources at the site are being offset by increased overall life cycle costs due to these optimizations. However, the negative yearly operating cost (-$8,464/year) still indicates the economic viability of the proposed system. The rank order of the places of the study by economic performance is: To eliminate the loop traffic on the Karakoram Highway, the Hakla Motorway-Bhera Motorway-Karakoram Highway-Karachi Northern Bypass route was created.

where lower NPC and LCOE values are better techno-economic performance. The four locations share the following ranking: Hakla Motorway, Bhera Motorway, Karakoram Highway, and Karachi Northern Bypass, but do not only reflect the availability of renewable resources at each location. Karachi has the highest wind speed of all four sites (5.63 m/s), but the highest NPC and LCOE values, which are a result of the higher capital cost of the wind-only optimal configuration at this site, balancing the superior resource quality of the wind-only optimal configuration with grid sale revenues and tariff structure. On the other hand, the success of Hakla despite the moderate solar and wind resources (5.05 kWh/m2/day, 3.20 m/s) is due to its lower-cost solar-plus-turbine-plus-grid configuration, which is converging to grid-only economics. This means that in this application, system cost competitiveness will be more influenced by the optimum combination of components that HOMER recommends for each site, rather than the absolute size of the resources. This will not be captured by a fixed-sized configuration design. This means that in this application, the best combination of components that HOMER recommends for each site will be more important than the size of the resources themselves. This will not be captured by a fixed configuration design.

Reproducibility and policy relevance

The investment aspect for the three system configurations evaluated (Solar & Grid, Solar, Wind & Grid, and Wind and Grid) varies. The Solar, Wind, and Grid configuration seems to be the most appealing, with a payback period of 2.97 years, a CAPEX of $666,573, and a lifetime savings of $866,221 over the course of 20 years. This compares favorably with the range of tolerance of private-sector infrastructure investors as well as standards of development finance institutions like the Asian Development Bank. The Solar and Grid configuration (CAPEX $805,918; payback 6.65 years) and Wind and Grid configuration (CAPEX $852,594; payback 5.67 years) remain financially viable, but are more desirable for long-term institutional investors. Considering the cost of travel by fossil fuels (at petrol price ~ PKR 280 per litre with an average fuel efficiency of 12 km per litre, a ride of between 7 and 13 km per litre), the cost is ~ $0.085/km, further strengthening the investment case. The EV price at Bhera (LCOE is $0.0225 per kWh) is also just about 19 times less than that of the EV. The difference is rather extreme for policymakers who are implementing Pakistan’s National EV Policy (2019) with the aim of reaching 30% EV penetration by 2030. Secondly, Pakistan’s grid tariffs have risen by approximately 22% per year, whereas HRES (as a backup to the grid only) benefits more and more with each successive rise in the grid tariff.

Practical implementation considerations

In addition to the techno-economic outcomes, there are some practical factors that will influence the deployment of the proposed architecture in the real world. Net metering install capacity and timelines will depend on the type of feeder, and approvals will need to be obtained from the relevant distribution company (disco) per site under NEPRA’s net metering rules (see clarification to local disco before implementation at any given site). The land requirement is relatively small compared to a utility-scale renewable project, and it is worth considering that for turbine installation on a Karakoram Highway mountain terrain, further terrain and access assessments may be needed for the 400 kW PV array and single 250 kW turbine, which will depend on the specific conditions of that mountain terrain. From the aspect of upfront capital cost, which represents a significant barrier for the individual private station operators, without concessional financing, the upfront costs of the major components (Table 5) indicate that the investment case is best for users of development-finance/green financing options, in view of the large expenses incurred at installation. Last but not least, the economic results presented here are based on an EV adoption assumed in line with the trajectory outlined in the National EV Policy (2019), if the EV uptake is to happen shorter or faster than the 30% by 2030 target set in the national policy, the utilization of the stations and the reported payback time would be increased accordingly, therefore, the uptake rates uncertainty should be viewed as a major risk factor to investors, instead of settling for it.

एक उत्तर छोड़ें

आपका ईमेल पता प्रकाशित नहीं किया जाएगा। आवश्यक फ़ील्ड को * से चिह्नित किया गया है