Flatter isn’t always better: The case for workplace hierarchies


He explained that the idea is to measure and reward the virtues an organization values when deciding who to recruit, keep and promote.

He also pointed to David Hallberg, artistic director of The Australian Ballet, who promoted two dancers to the company’s highest rank, principal artist, after a performance of Swan Lake at the Sydney Opera House. He made the announcement from the stage and explained the criteria behind his decision to the audience of 1,400 people.

“We’re achieving C and P and R all at once,” Halevy said. “We’re showing that we can share leadership. We’re showing that we’re accountable to the criteria based on which we’re promoting.”

Where HR comes in

Halevy’s advice for HR leaders starts with parallel hierarchies. In healthcare, where HRD America has reported on workers who keep showing up despite burnout, he said administrators, nurses and physicians aren’t compared on the same metric. He said HR can build the same approach by developing tools that evaluate different kinds of contributors on different dimensions, which helps people advance on their own terms.

Halevy also described what he calls the power without status effect. Some roles, such as those in charge of budgets or reimbursements, carry real power but don’t earn much respect from colleagues. He said his research, including lab studies and work with federal government leaders and managers, found that combination to be particularly toxic.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *