The Legend of Zelda franchise is undoubtedly one of the greatest and most well-known video game franchise of all-time. The Ocarina of Time remake came out for the Switch 2 this week to critical and fan acclaim. On that note, Jason and I wanted to take the time to celebrate some of the other great games in the Zelda franchise and discuss some of our favorites.
Jason’s top 3 ranking
1. Twilight Princess
My favorite Zelda title of all-time. This was released in the waning days of the Gamecube and I believe was also a launch title for Nintendo’s new console, the Wii. Having never owned a Wii (yes, I’ve never played Skyward Sword), I played this on the Gamecube. This was many gamers’ preferred way of playing because of the Wii motion controls.
We were delivered this game just FOUR YEARS after Wind Waker, which is so impressive given the current state of game development where we are lucky to get a new game in a franchise every decade. This game delivered on the promise of a fully-realized both Adult Link and updated graphics that we all saw capable of seven years prior.
I like when Zelda gets weird and here you get to play as both an Adult sword-swinging Link and a transformed wolf-version of himself. Later in the game you can actually switch between the two at-will to accomplish certain tasks and both have their own unique combat sets. You are accompanied by the greatest Zelda companion character in the series, Midna. A little impish creature whose motives aren’t entirely clear most of the game and often makes fun of you while giving you hints. She is lovely and actually feels like a part of the story instead of a hand-holding mechanism (hello Navi and Tatl).
The gameplay is outstanding as you travel across this new and realistic Hyrule where you get to meet all sorts of weird characters, fish (the best fishing mini-game in the series) and truly inventive dungeons. Goron Mines, Snowpeak Ruins, Arbiter Grounds, and Palace of Twilight are among the best dungeons in the series. Snowpeak Ruins might be the best of all-time if you are asking me today. The character design of Link, Zelda, Ganon and the entirety of Hyrule is just impeccable with its realistic, but yet fantastical approach.
The story might be my favorite told in the series (runner-up to Breath of the Wild). Its ending is so good and yet so devastating that I’ve hoped for years we’d get some sort of follow-up to it (like a Majora’s Mask or Tears of the Kingdom) to no avail. If I were to recommend a gamer to start the series, this would be the game I’d point them to.
2. Majora’s Mask
Apologies to those who need to hear this, but Majora’s Mask is a superior game and experience to Ocarina of Time. OoT isn’t a bad game, but MM is so unique and weird that it completely draws you in. MM’s story picks up right after OoT as Link searches for the most annoying companion character, Navi (LISTEN!!!!). You come across a previous side character, Skull Kid, who has absconded the deadly Majora’s Mask and whisked you through time to a different universe and world altogether. Here you tackle all the classic dungeon crawling and exploration of OoT, but give you unique obstacles and tools to accomplish your tasks. Majora’s mask isn’t the only mask in the game as you can collect a couple dozen masks that either transform you completely (into a Deku shrub, Goron, Zora, etc) or give you special abilities (Bunny Mask allows you to run faster, etc). The latter mostly help you solve the various sidequests throughout the game that you must navigate with the in-game three-day timer clock. Why must you complete things before the three days are up? Skull Kid is using Majora’s Mask to crash it into Termini, killing everyone. Certain tasks and storylines can only be completed on certain days and certain times. To navigate all this, you use the Ocarina of Time to go back to the first day to complete all these missions.
The game just feels so experimental and fun. Rolling around as a Goron or gliding through water as a Zora felt so liberating. You never felt chained to Link’s default abilities. I can also appreciate a Zelda title that doesn’t rely on the normal Link/Zelda/Ganon storyline. It delivers you something fresh, new and exciting.
3. Wind Waker
To understand this Zelda game, you must delve into its initial controversy. In the year 2000, Nintendo showcased the power of the Gamecube console with a fully rendered trailer of an adult Link in a duel with Ganondorf. It was impressive and exciting at the time to see such a graphical leap from the N64-era Zelda games. Fast-forward a year, Nintendo premiered its new Zelda game trailer and it looked nothing like what was shown previously. As you can see, Nintendo pivoted to a cell-shaded overly-cartooney version of The Legend of Zelda, with no Hyrule…and people were not happy.
The game was released and it’s safe to say that the backlash was entirely unwarranted. While this game featured artwork entirely different from what we expected, the game was a resounding success. Replicating the classic Zelda-formula, but in a new style…and on a boat. I love when Zelda gets weird and this doesn’t disappoint. Your companion character is a talking boat who is inhabited by the spirit of the last king of Hyrule. There are also some really great twists in this one involving the fate of Hyrule, Ganon, and Zelda herself. You get all the classic dungeons all the while exploring the various islands scattered across the map as you traverse the vast blue ocean. Some folks will complain about the latter and you only really feel the sailing fatigue as you search for the missing Tri-Force shards.
The story is heartfelt, you control the wind and weather with a magic wand, it gives Link a family and the series an adventure unlike anything it has done before and that hasn’t been seen again.
Steve’s top 3 ranking
1. Twilight Princess
My favorite Zelda is ALSO Twilight Princess! I actually did play this on the Wii, and I LOVED the motion controls. You could use the Wii remote and nunchuck as Link’s sword and shield. This made for an amazing, immersive experience that made this Zelda feel so different from any other game in the series. Swinging the sword as you finish off an enemy just feels right.
On top of this, Twilight Princess utilizes a darker tone and feel than most of the previous games in the series. There is a desperation and fear that other games in the series lack.
The wolf Link sequences are so unique to the rest of the series. They are initially an annoying change of pace, and getting bossed around by Midna can be grating. Once you get used to that style of play, it creates an interesting challenge and gives the game a dimension that cannot be found elsewhere.
Midna is such a huge part of the overall experience. I echo Jason’s sentiment that she feels like more of an actual companion in this game. Ultimately, this is her story as the actual Twilight Princess.
2. A Link to the Past
A Link to the Past is the primary Zelda game of my youth. I played the OG Legend of Zelda with its iconic gold NES cartridge back in the day and it was truly groundbreaking. Zelda II felt odd and not like a proper sequel. A Link to the Past scratched that itch.
A Link to the Past has one of the best stories for a Zelda game, utilizing the contrast between good and evil by featuring both a Light World and a Dark World. As a kid, I always found the Dark World a little bit unsettling and a little scary, even though it was a 16-bit over the top view game.
A Link to the Past has one of the best introductions of any Zelda game, with Link’s Uncle being awakened in the middle of the night to go rescue Zelda from Agahnim. Link follows and receives a sword and shield from his Uncle, who was mortally wounded during his rescue attempt. It’s as dark of an intro as any Zelda game has and a fantastic way to set the tone for what is to come.
A Link to the Past tells a surprisingly complex story for a 16 bit game. The conflict with Agahnim is a nice contrast to the battles with Ganon in most Zelda games (if you’ve played this game, yes, I know). This is a beautifully crafted game and about as good as things get on the Super Nintendo.
3. Breath of the Wild/Tears of the Kingdom
We cheated a little bit and combined Breath of the Wild (BOTW) and Tears of the Kingdom (TOTK) into one here. It makes a lot of sense, since they’re almost like one huge game and one of the rare direct sequels in Zelda history.
If there is a criticism of these games, it’s that they are too open. There is too much to do. The amount of detail built into these open worlds is incredible. You can spend days just romping around BOTW and TOTK without even considering the main story. The ability to think about the box and complete the puzzles in the game in the way that suits your brain best is really great and gives you space for creativity in a way that few games do.
Beyond the creativity and openness, BOTW and TOTK tell a lovely story about Hyrule’s origins and rebuilding after dark times. The final battles in these games are not the most challenging in the series, but they have a magical feel that makes the end of these games feel special. BOTW and TOTK are beautifully crafted games that maximize the concept of open world gaming.