Summer 2026 brought a dramatic upsurge in the number of high-profile transfers of 16- and 17-year-old players between the academies of the Premier League’s ‘Big Six’.
More and more players are de-registering from their clubs before signing scholarship terms and moving — the most recent, and most high-profile, case being 16-year-old JJ Gabriel informing Manchester United he wants to leave the club amid interest from Real Madrid.
However, while these moves have generated many headlines in recent months, a new frontier has opened at an even younger age: under-14 transfers.
“The under-14 transfer market has been busier than the first-team transfer market. That’s how mad it has become,” says one Premier League head of academy recruitment.
This transfer market has reached Year 10 (the equivalent in the U.S. of sophomore year of high school). Almost 50 under-14 players across the Premier League and EFL have de-registered from their academies at that age over the past two summers.
Players are afforded a window at under-12, under-14 and under-16 levels during which they can de-register from their clubs, an essential step if they wish to sign for another team, so the number is a good guide as to how many youngsters are moving.
Young prospects themselves cannot receive a wage from clubs until they turn 17, but academy transfers are big business.
An academy losing a young player is entitled to a compensation payment from any new club, representing some of their lost investment in the individual. Compensation levels are set out in a table by the Premier League, but if clubs think a player’s potential justifies it, they can seek to privately agree an enhanced fee with an acquiring team, or they ask a tribunal for an uplift to recognise the youngster’s trajectory. Some of these fees can now rival the money spent on first-team signings.
The Athletic has spoken to multiple sources inside English clubs’ academies and at agencies representing players to find out what is happening within this age group. These sources spoke on the condition of anonymity, in order to speak candidly and to protect jobs and relationships.
The commoditisation of young players and the risks to academies
One 14-year-old, who we are not naming due to his age, attracted attention from most of the top academies in the country and de-registered from his club in May.
It was a surprise to one of the bidders, however, when their six-figure compensation offer was seen as an amusing sum by the chief executive of the club the player was leaving — they had already turned down £1million from another team.
“You can start to see the player they are going to end up as, but in all my years scouting, the only player I have ever seen at 14 (who was) nailed-on to make it at the very top is (current Arsenal rising star) Max Dowman. So many things can happen or go wrong,” says one head of academy recruitment.
Some agents and recruitment chiefs argue that the calibre of players emerging is now so high that these teenagers are akin to full-time professionals at a younger age than before, which is reflected in academies’ heavy investment at young age groups. Others view it as commodifying kids too early.
“Strip it back and it is disguised trafficking,” says a Championship head of recruitment.
And with the aggressive pursuit of youth players at under-14s level who are seen as a revenue stream for clubs lower down the game’s food chain, at what point does that become an existential problem for academies?
A Category 1 (the highest of the three levels) academy’s recruitment chief tells The Athletic their club have made close to £20million on under-18s player transfers in the past five years, but they are frustrated at not being able to realise the full values of these prospects by bringing them through to their first team.
Training compensation amounts were increased by 70 per cent in 2022-23, and appearance fee contingency compensation was also raised in the same season by 100 per cent to ensure developing clubs are able to receive up to £3m from former academy players that make 100 appearances at the highest level.
But the costs of running an academy with the provisions required are becoming prohibitive, particularly for Category 2 and 3 operations — in some cases costing more than £10m a year. Academies are rated Category 1, 2, 3 and the funding tapers down from 1 to 3, as does the compensation due.
Academies for English Football League (EFL) clubs — the 72 clubs across the three divisions below the Premier League — receive grant funding to help support youth development, sustain the football pyramid and produce homegrown talent. The Premier League and EFL confirmed that grant funding, compensation and the tribunal process are forming a part of the ongoing re-negotiation between the two bodies over a new funding deal.
But two academy chiefs in the lower categories express fears over the long-term future of their line of work.
“Academy football is gone. It’s absolutely broken,” says one. “Some will point to (Chelsea forwards) Cole Palmer and Morgan Rogers as the poster boys, but underneath it there is this horrible, money-driven greed that is killing academy football.”
Another says: “(Club) Owners will turn around at some stage and say, ‘It is costing me too much to run this academy, why are we doing it?’. If they are not careful, I can see it potentially imploding over the next 10 years.”
Chelsea’s Palmer and Rogers came through the English academy system (Mike Egerton/PA Images via Getty Images)
The impact on young players, the role of agents and the need for reform
Most of our sources reported that, in their experience, it is now highly unusual for any player to move at age 14 without having a clear idea of what they expect their future scholar and professional contracts to look like.
A scholarship, which kicks in at 16, does not usually bring in big money, even for the elite talents, but many players will have a picture of what they expect their professional contract to look like and will be in negotiations before their next birthday, so they are ready to sign the day they turn 17.
And with such enormous wages on offer from age 17, it is hardly surprising that young players and their families are jostling for position and that agents are involved.
The vast majority of these prospects are from families with lower-to-average-income backgrounds and many have no experience in professional football. They and their loved ones can reach out to the Premier League or the Professional Footballers’ Association (effectively the players’ trade union in England) for legal advice, but it is understandably hard to resist the lure of a professional deal they are told could be worth tens of thousands of pounds a week when they turn 17.
“I would challenge any parent who claims that they would outright reject (the possibility of) these sums if it was offered to their son,” says one academy chief.
It is a view echoed by many other academy and agent sources.
“If the money is there, the market will dictate what the talent gets. But is earning £20,000 a week at 17 healthy?” says a head of recruitment at one academy. “You are a very brave family to turn it down. I just worry that we are making monsters out of these boys.”
One proposal is for the money to be ring-fenced until the player reaches an age at which they have the maturity and financial literacy to cope with such sums, but even then, there are concerns about the impact of knowing in advance they have the potential to earn these sorts of riches.
As for the agents, under FA rules, players cannot be formally represented until they turn 16. However, more than two dozen high-ranking sources at academies and in the agency world all said it is an open secret that agents are manoeuvring in the under-14 age group, acting as unpaid ‘advisors’ to families.
There are hundreds of agents authorised by the FA to represent minors (under-18 players) and a number of them are active at under-14 level. There is a general acceptance that when it comes to exceptional talents, most big agencies will have a connection who can get them an introduction to the child’s parents. At least three big, British-owned agencies have hired recruitment chiefs from leading Premier League clubs to run their in-house talent identification departments in a bid to secure the next batch of stars.
Competition is stiff.
One agent tells The Athletic that he met a father to discuss representing his son once the boy turned 16, only to be told the player had been ‘with’ an agency since 11, and that it had invested so much money in individual coaching and trips abroad that he did not feel he could switch to someone else. Although sourcing training sessions is not breaking any rules, it shows the soft power that agents can gain in the years preceding the signing of players’ first professional contracts.
There is a lot of competition to represent players at young ages (Tim Clayton/Corbis via Getty Images)
Agents act as a conduit between the player, their family and the buying club. Even though it can be years until the youngster earns a professional wage, families are often attracted by what some agents are telling them those future salaries might be. These sums easily surpass five figures for the big clubs, and the notion can incentivise players and their loved ones to make a move rather than stay at their current academy.
So too can some of the offers from agents. One of the popular arrangements in the under-14 range, according to agents and academy chiefs, is for the would-be representative to suggest that they will split 50 per cent of their future commission on any professional player contract with the family.
Every source consulted for this piece said what agents have been doing at this age group has been an open secret for decades. It is the recent increase in the number of players moving at these lower ages, and the exorbitant fees and wages from when they then turn 17 and 18, that has drawn more attention to this area of the industry.
One of the reasons parents of promising young players are drawn to talking to agents is that they feel the clubs do not always act in their child’s best interests. Some parents see this as a club denying the lad the opportunity to join a bigger or better club.
Several agents say this obfuscation is part of the reason their counterparts are operating at these ages, as they believe their presence is necessary.
“A lot of people have got fed up with trying to do it the right way,” says one agent. “Go early, or you’re last.”
The Premier League is aware of the issue, with two academy sources saying that the possible introduction of an independent mediator to oversee youth transfers and ensure greater transparency has been discussed at points in the past few years.
The suggestion raised during Premier League meetings was that this department could act as a conduit between clubs and inform players and their families of potential transfer interest. But multiple academy chiefs and agents, including a Premier League source, express doubt that any tightening of the existing system can completely guard against rule breaches.
An FA spokesperson told The Athletic: “The FA has clear regulations for agents acting in respect of minors and we have a strong track record of enforcement when such breaches occur. We would ask anyone with credible information of breaches to provide this to us.”
Social media and sponsorship deals
Transfers at these junior ages used to go under the radar. And for safeguarding reasons, the Premier League and EFL do not allow clubs to post on social media about any players aged under 16. So it is a cause for concern that there are now anonymous accounts dedicated exclusively to recording the exploits of these children, with one boasting almost 300,000 followers on Instagram.
On one occasion this summer, a high-profile account documenting the exploits of English youth players inaccurately reported that an under-14 player at an EFL club had de-registered and would be looking for a new team this summer. It was wrong, as the player was staying. The club concerned reported them to the EFL over safeguarding concerns. The EFL confirmed it has engaged directly with both owners of such accounts and clubs around the importance of safeguarding.
An experienced coach at a Category 2 academy realised how pervasive these social-media accounts have become when he eavesdropped on the conversation some of his under-15s players were having at the back of the team bus.
Social media is increasing the promotion of younger players (Alan Harvey/SNS Group via Getty Images)
“They were discussing the boys getting moves, the video clips and how this boy doesn’t wear Adidas because he has a boot deal,” he says.
“Instagram is the bush telegraph now. That’s when I sadly realised they’re not interested in staying. Their mindset is in a place of self-promotion, and because they’re all looking at the same things, it self-perpetuates and feeds this mentality of instant gratification.”
The same coach recalls a review meeting with an under-14s player and his family at the end of a season. Positive feedback was given, and everyone seemed content. The next morning, however, the club received a letter from the family telling them they would be de-registering.
“It’s soul-destroying, as it feels like they’re kicking sand in your face,” the coach says.
“The beauty of the job and the wonder of being a developer of young people is to see them succeed and be part of that journey. Many of us do it for modest money. It breaks your heart when you work hard to help straighten a lot of these boys out and don’t reap the reward. Loyalty as a value is disappearing.”
Contract-signing days, even at under-nines level, have now become an event, with some clubs printing the players’ names on the back of a team shirt and allowing pictures to be taken on the pitch at their stadium. Some parents even put together signing videos for social media, and one academy coach says he had families ask for the same VIP treatment as a different player got the previous year when they got to meet the first-team manager.
“I came out of it because of the politics and the over-professionalisation of it all,” says a former coach at a major English academy.
“The heads of recruitment are in a rat race. It used to be that you had a relationship and developed a boy since nine, but now no one is a***d about having local lads. They are going after all the big talents rather than looking at what is in the building. If they can get them young, and quickly get them into the first team, or flip them, it is all good for their CV.”
Several agents and academy chiefs predicted it will become more common for players to move at both 14 and 16.
“Soon, they’re going to run out of 14-year-olds to sign, as that will get too expensive as well,” says a chief youth scout at a Category 1 club.
“What’s next, 12? Where does this end?”