Survey Finds Over Eighty Percent of Egyptian Public Hospital Doctors Face


A cross-sectional investigation assessing occupational hazards within Egyptian healthcare facilities has revealed that 82.7 percent of surveyed physicians experienced workplace violence, with verbal hostility predominating over physical contact. Conducted across two major public institutions in Alexandria, the study evaluated both lifetime and recent exposures while systematically analyzing how clinicians perceive existing workplace protections. Published in the Journal of the Egyptian Public Health Association, the findings document that 61.7 percent of participating practitioners sustained verbal aggression over the preceding twelve months, whereas 8.3 percent endured physical violence during that same interval. Furthermore, witnessing aggressive behavior was nearly universal across the surveyed cohort, with 95.1 percent observing hostile encounters at some point in their careers, 95.4 percent witnessing verbal abuse within the previous year, and 40.0 percent observing physical attacks over the same twelve-month timeframe. In addition, 95.4 percent of the participating medical staff reported experiencing persistent apprehension regarding potential exposure to hostility while executing their clinical responsibilities.

To capture operational conditions outside academic medical centers, researchers Mai E. El-Shishtawy, Wafaa W. Guirguis, Gehan R. Zaki, and Taghareed A. Elhoseny directed their investigation toward non-university facilities, which frequently manage significant patient volumes under constrained resources. Data collection took place between August and November 2023 utilizing a convenience sample of 324 doctors recruited from two prominent healthcare centers: the largest local facility administered by the Ministry of Health and Population, contributing 141 respondents, and the largest facility operated under the Health Insurance Organization, supplying 183 respondents. Minimum sample sizes were determined using Epi Info software based on total facility medical staff populations of 220 and 349 physicians, respectively, setting an expected 50 percent prior exposure rate to achieve a 95 percent confidence level with 5 percent precision. Clinicians completed an English-language, pre-validated self-administered questionnaire structured into three analytical divisions measuring sociodemographic factors, exact characteristics of violent encounters, and perceptions of environmental and organizational safety safeguards.

Demographic evaluations of the study cohort revealed that 79.6 percent of participating clinicians were aged 40 years or younger, with 50.3 percent identifying as male and 51.9 percent being unmarried. Professional classifications showed that resident physicians comprised 58.9 percent of the sample, while 62.7 percent possessed a decade or less of professional medical experience, and 47.5 percent practiced within general medical specialties. Statistical assessments demonstrated significant associations between participant characteristics and the probability of experiencing hostility. Specifically, younger chronological age between 30 and 40 years, unmarried marital status, and working in a resident physician rank were significantly linked with sustaining verbal abuse, yielding p-values of 0.009, 0.002, and less than 0.001, respectively. Similarly, physical violence exposure correlated significantly with single marital status and possessing fewer years of work experience, recording p-values of 0.008 and 0.038, reflecting the pronounced vulnerability of junior clinical staff during initial clinical career stages.

When examining the detailed anatomy of recent hostile encounters, the authors found that verbal abuse manifested overwhelmingly as shouting, reported in 93.5 percent of incidents, followed by foul language at 34.0 percent and direct spoken threats at 12.5 percent. In contrast, physical assaults predominantly entailed pushing, identified in 92.5 percent of physical episodes, accompanied by kicking and direct hitting, each documented in 7.4 percent of events. In both categories of aggression, patients themselves were rarely the perpetrators, as family members and accompanying visitors committed 76.0 percent of verbal incidents and 88.9 percent of physical assaults. Timing patterns also varied systematically by violence category, with verbal episodes occurring largely during morning shifts at 41.5 percent and evening shifts at 38.0 percent, whereas physical assaults concentrated heavily during evening shifts at 48.2 percent and night shifts at 29.6 percent, coinciding with peak visitor hours and reduced presence of senior hospital staff.

Hospital location mapping demonstrated that emergency departments represented the primary physical locus for violence, accounting for 49.5 percent of verbal encounters and 70.4 percent of physical altercations, while outpatient departments witnessed 28.5 percent of verbal and 11.1 percent of physical events. Clinical activity assessments established that attacks occurred most frequently while physicians were actively conducting patient examinations or taking histories, encompassing 46.0 percent of verbal and 37.0 percent of physical confrontations, or while attending to neighboring patients, involving 42.5 percent of verbal and 44.4 percent of physical cases. Clinicians identified systemic operating friction as the foremost trigger for aggression rather than personal dispute. Specifically, patient refusal of institutional policies triggered 40.0 percent of verbal incidents, alongside heavy clinical workloads at 35.0 percent, extended waiting times at 34.5 percent, and acute patient conditions at 19.0 percent. Physical aggression was provoked by heavy workloads and prolonged waiting periods at 37.0 percent each, acute medical conditions at 33.3 percent, and policy disputes at 29.6 percent.

The professional toll of workplace aggression was pronounced, as 69.0 percent of verbally abused clinicians and 74.1 percent of physically assaulted doctors reported subsequent declines in job performance and personal career satisfaction, with verbal attacks frequently interrupting the ongoing delivery of bedside patient care. A striking proportion of victims contemplated leaving their employment following these events, with 34.0 percent considering resignation after verbal altercations, among whom 75.0 percent planned to emigrate abroad. Following physical attacks, 66.7 percent considered quitting, with 83.0 percent of those intending to leave the country entirely. Despite this considerable distress, formal institutional reporting remained virtually nonexistent. Administrative complaints were withheld by 99.0 percent of verbal abuse victims and 88.9 percent of physical assault victims, with clinicians citing administrative negligence toward past complaints, informal apologies from perpetrators, and widespread ignorance regarding reporting mechanisms as primary deterrents.

Perceptions of structural security and architectural safeguards, evaluated on a three-point Likert scale converted into percentage scores, revealed substantial functional disparities between the two public facilities. Environmental layout factors showed comparable aggregate limitations, but individual measures differed markedly. For instance, designated protective retreat spaces, emergency escape exits, restricted reception access, comfortable waiting accommodations, and clear patient observation lines achieved significantly higher positive ratings within the Health Insurance Organization hospital at 30.1, 32.8, 32.8, 35.5, and 39.9 percent, compared to 4.9, 0.7, 4.3, 7.8, and 17.0 percent in the Ministry facility (p < 0.001). Conversely, the Ministry of Health and Population hospital scored higher on adequate visibility lighting at 89.4 versus 77.6 percent, waiting zones clear of improvised weapons at 96.5 versus 52.5 percent, work areas free of potential weapons at 89.4 versus 54.7 percent, and furniture configurations preventing entrapment at 84.4 versus 63.4 percent (p < 0.001).

Organizational domains derived from standard Occupational Safety and Health Administration prevention criteria demonstrated further operational contrasts across the participating institutions. Staffing and resource evaluations placed both hospitals in a moderate prevention tier, though the Ministry facility secured a significantly higher median percentage score of 77.8 percent compared to 66.7 percent for the insurance hospital (Mann-Whitney U = 9739.5, p < 0.001). Ministry doctors reported higher compliance regarding avoiding solo working arrangements at 97.2 versus 66.7 percent, maintaining adequate physician staffing ratios at 89.4 versus 58.5 percent, knowing security personnel by name at 88.7 versus 63.4 percent, and receiving adequate clinical equipment at 80.1 versus 85.5 percent. However, specialized electronic security infrastructure was virtually absent in both centers, with metal detection gates and functional panic alarm networks acknowledged by only 3.3 percent of insurance personnel, while Ministry staff reported door residence locks at 0.0 percent, internal emergency phones at 5.0 percent, and dedicated police stations at 0.7 percent.

Institutional procedural protocols and administrative support systems demonstrated extensive systemic deficits, with both centers scoring in the poor prevention tier below sixty percent. In the domain of security and workplace prevention procedures, the Health Insurance Organization facility achieved a median score of 50.0 percent and 30.0 percent respectively, surpassing the Ministry facility’s corresponding medians of 16.7 percent and 26.7 percent (U = 9685.0 and 11073.0, p < 0.001). Nonetheless, basic procedural compliance such as identification badge usage was maintained by 91.5 percent of Ministry physicians. Organizational backing after violent incidents remained minimal, registering medians of 25.0 percent in the insurance facility and 12.5 percent in the Ministry hospital (U = 933.0, p < 0.001). Furthermore, post-incident administrative investigations were omitted in 97.5 percent of verbal and 88.9 percent of physical cases, cementing widespread practitioner perceptions that organizational reporting yielded no constructive remediation.

The most severe deficiency identified across the investigation concerned professional safety training, where both hospitals recorded median and minimum percentage scores of zero. The maximum recorded training score reached only 42.9 percent in the insurance hospital and 14.3 percent in the Ministry facility (U = 11815.5, p = 0.001), indicating that structured instruction on de-escalation, conflict mitigation, and legal reporting was absent for nearly all practicing clinicians. Emphasizing national healthcare accreditation benchmarks established by the General Authority for Healthcare Accreditation and Regulation alongside federal guidelines from the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, the investigators concluded that curbing medical brain drain and protecting healthcare workers necessitates structural institutional reform, standardized surveillance databases, enforceable visitor restriction policies, upgraded architectural engineering controls, and mandatory, routine violence prevention training throughout Egyptian public hospitals.

Subject of Research: Workplace violence prevalence and institutional preventive measures among Egyptian public hospital physicians

Article Title: Prevalence and physicians’ perception of workplace violence preventive measures in two Egyptian public hospitals

Article References: El-Shishtawy, M. E., Guirguis, W. W., Zaki, G. R., & Elhoseny, T. A. (2026). Prevalence and physicians’ perception of workplace violence preventive measures in two Egyptian public hospitals. Journal of the Egyptian Public Health Association, 101(1), Article 11. https://doi.org/10.1186/s42506-026-00213-6

Image Credits: AI Generated

DOI: 10.1186/s42506-026-00213-6

Keywords: workplace violence, hospital physicians, Alexandria, emergency department, healthcare safety, Health Insurance Organization, Ministry of Health and Population, occupational hazards, verbal abuse, physical assault, OSHA guidelines, resident physicians, incident reporting, workplace procedures, institutional support, healthcare accreditation

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *