A succession and wealth-division dispute has emerged within the Venu Srinivasan branch of the TVS Group, with his daughter, Lakshmi Venu, formally seeking a partition of joint family assets held under the VS Trust. She contends that the 2020 group settlement did not divide ownership within her immediate family.
If the dispute escalates into a legal battle, it could drain management bandwidth, potentially affecting listed entities and worrying investors, warns Shriram Subramanian, Founder and Managing Director of InGovern.
Speaking to The Federal, Subramanian explains the corporate governance challenges surrounding family trusts, the distinction between management control and economic ownership, and what the rift means for minority shareholders.
Edited excerpts:
How do trust-based structures complicate ownership and control in family-owned Indian businesses, and where do risks of a potential breach of trust arise?
In trust-based structures, the first question is who gets to know the details of the trust, specifically minority shareholders. Particularly in listed companies, minority shareholders need clarity on who the ultimate beneficial owners of the majority shareholder are. When a trust is created, like the VS Trust or trusts in other business groups, the ultimate beneficial owner can change. This is precisely why the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) introduced guidelines requiring even the beneficial owners of trusts to be disclosed.
Also read: Legal fault line in Laksmi Venu vs Venu Srinivasan row: Management vs money
That is where non-transparency for minority shareholders of listed companies kicks in. Shareholders may not know who the actual beneficiaries of a trust are — a VS Trust or any trust can be named, yet outsiders may not know who stands behind it. Furthermore, if the trustees decide to alter the constitution of the trust and change the beneficiaries, that process is also not very transparent to minority shareholders.
TVS Motor, TVS Holdings, TVS Credit, and Sundaram-Clayton are either listed or closely linked to listed entities. Should minority shareholders and investors be worried, and what disclosures should come from the boards?
At this stage, there is not much impact on the listed companies, as they have their own strong management teams. Obviously, the largest listed company, with a market capitalisation exceeding Rs 2 lakh crore, is TVS Motor Company. Investors, including institutional investors holding substantial blocks of shares in TVS Motor, will be watching developments closely.
As of now, it remains a private family dispute. Of course, if it escalates in the courts and prolonged, acrimonious battles ensue, and if the management bandwidth and resources of the family and TVS Motor are strained, then investors will get worried. For now, the impact is limited.
Lakshmi Venu has argued that managing a business does not confer exclusive ownership. How well do Indian promoter families separate management from ownership, and what happens to board independence when a family is divided?
Very rarely is the division, especially among siblings or family members, entirely clear. Managing a business is often viewed as grooming an individual to eventually inherit the asset. That is precisely where the contention arises: actual economic ownership is not divided, only management responsibility. Because one sibling manages Business A while another manages Business B, that operational arrangement should not dictate the division of wealth among siblings. That is the core contention here and in many similar cases.
Also read: TVS family feud: Lakshmi Venu serves partition notice to father Venu Srinivasan
As for the boards, they have no direct role in this because it concerns the internal division of wealth within a family and promoter group.
We have seen similar rifts in other business families like Ambani, Godrej, and Murugappa. How do such disputes typically affect a company’s value and reputation?
Investors will track developments closely, and media coverage will naturally shed light on the latest proceedings, which is healthy. Investors will watch where these disputes are headed and what the logical conclusion might be. Unless the dispute becomes overly acrimonious and drains management bandwidth, there is no loss of reputation to the company.
Could this TVS litigation have any spill-over impact on companies in the Amalgamations Group?
That is a completely different business family and business group. Only Mallika Srinivasan holds minority shares in TAFE and may have claims to certain assets within the Amalgamations Group, which is for them to settle internally. I do not think the issues within the Venu Srinivasan group impact the Amalgamations Group in any way.