Grand Theft Auto San Andreas review: all you had to do was follow one of the best games of all time, CJ


Gaming

The moment when GTA met RPGs, and spawned memes that would last decades

Published: 18 Nov 2026

This wasn’t an easy game to make. By 2004, Rockstar Games had been on a tear of 3D open world titles that redefined action games, spawned numerous imitators and earned consistently giddy praise from critics. How could they top GTA III and Vice City with the series’ next instalment? And without a new console generation to exploit?

By looking out beyond the series’ established influences – Scarface, Elite, and Scarface – to role-playing games. The way they let you feel ownership of your protagonist by levelling up their abilities, and the way their worlds felt reactive to your deeds. San Andreas isn’t a role-playing game by any stretch, but neither did it want to stay in the series’ previously defined lane and just give you a new map to run riot in.

Advertisement – Page continues below

And so, the burger-chomping, bench-pressing vest connoisseur Carl ‘CJ’ Johnson was born.

Having given a voice to the protagonist a game prior, Rockstar went further into developing the player-character’s, er, character this time. CJ has a more involving backstory and emotional spectrum than Tommy Vercetti, whose own range extends from ‘annoyed mobster’ to ‘really, really annoyed mobster’.

He’s a far more sympathetic thug, forced into a life of crime by circumstance and driven by loyalty and friendship more than Vercetti’s ruthless ambition. Not that the SAPD officers he guns down will take much comfort from that.

But the biggest change to CJ as a protagonist is in how much you shape him as a player. He has character stats for muscle, fat, lung capacity, stamina, respect and sex appeal. What those stat values are depends on what you spend your time doing. A life of burgers and driving everywhere leads to a visibly chubby CJ who can’t sprint for long and gets no street cred.

Advertisement – Page continues below

On the other hand, a regime built around gym work, cycling and the finest Noughties streetwear gives him better sprint capacity, a hench physique, and admiring glances.

This was the game that finally made good on delivering plot twists with real impact

GTA’s storytelling had been leaning into a more cinematic style since its first PS2 release, but this was the game that finally made good on delivering plot twists with real impact, and emotional payoffs that anyone who played it 22 years ago can still remember keenly. Oh, Big Smoke. We’ll say no more.

To achieve that, Rockstar wrote a lot more dialogue for this game and nestled its missions in higher levels of context and consequence. You always understand why you’re doing the next hare-brained scheme, what the Grove Street Gang’s hoping to achieve by doing it, and what grim things might happen if they don’t.

Get all the latest news, reviews and exclusives, direct to your inbox.

In all that increased dialogue, sharper characters are drawn. Older brother Sweet, childhood friend Ryder, insufferable wannabe rapper OG Loc, all have memorable eccentricities and voice acting performances that set a new bar in 2004. Samuel L. Jackson’s in this game!

All that dialogue, married with 2004’s best graphics and a particularly catchy west coast rap soundtrack, was always going to provide fertile ground for memes later down the line. And so would the occasionally hateful mission design, most notably Wrong Side Of The Tracks.

In this mission, Big Smoke tasks you with riding a dirt back along train lines, catching up with a freight train, jumping off a bridge and landing on the train carriage roof, before shooting the gangsters standing on it while straddling your dirt bike on that roof. It’s a feat of almost unfathomable dexterity and timing, and for Big Smoke to have the temerity to say “All you had to do was follow the damn train, CJ” each and every time you fail the mission, like it’s the simplest thing in the world, well, it still stings.

Maybe it is best remembered for the memes now, but that would be doing San Andreas a disservice. CJ walked – and dirtbiked – so that Jason and Lucia could run wild and free through Vice City, and we shouldn’t forget that.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *