Climate philanthropy cannot transform buildings without embracing industry


A collaboration between Realdania and Laudes Foundation shows the unique role philanthropy has in de-risking the shift to circular construction – but only if foundations are willing to work with the companies that ultimately have to make that transition happen.




A decade and a half of running philanthropy-funded programmes with the construction industry has left me with cautious optimism. While many companies are developing solutions that could transform construction and cut its emissions, building a viable business in an emerging market takes a long time. In my experience, it’s often a decade before an innovation gains real traction.




Consider a Danish manufacturer of precast concrete that is trying to take back structural slabs for reuse, reducing the need for newly produced components and the associated embodied carbon. They have encountered barriers at every step: recovering slabs during deconstruction, dealing with hazardous substances, documenting their load-bearing properties, transporting them without damage, storing them until another project needs them, and finding the right match in a new building.




While the technical solution may exist, the market around it often does not.




Buildings currently account for close to 40 per cent of global energy- and process-related carbon emissions, counting both their construction and operation. Yet only five per cent of climate philanthropy goes to the sector. In our work at Smith Innovation, where we run programmes funded by both Realdania and Laudes Foundation, I can see several reasons why this is the case.




Firstly, construction is a relatively underrepresented sector in policy and funding discussions. It is regulated through energy, housing, planning, waste, and procurement rules, often across different ministries and levels of government. Cutting emissions from construction also lacks the clear business case that helped draw money into technologies such as solar power and electric vehicles. Furthermore, the social consequences, for housing costs, employment and workers in a traditional industry, can be difficult to measure.




But there is another barrier I encounter repeatedly: many foundations are reluctant to work closely with commercial companies.




That matters because many of the barriers to circular construction sit inside commercial value chains. Manufacturers changing how they produce or recover products must develop new logistics, testing procedures, and documentation, often with no guarantee that anyone will buy the result. Designers and specifiers can face uncertainty around performance documentation, warranties, and liability when specifying reused components. Buyers may want circular solutions but lack common methods for assessing them.




Few companies will take on that risk alone. Private investors are equally unlikely to finance a new model until there is evidence that it can work.




This is where philanthropy can play a distinctive role by helping to build the shared market infrastructure that no single company has an incentive to create alone: common documentation methods, testing and assurance, better data, demonstration projects, procurement models, and evidence about what buyers actually need.




Two funders, two approaches, one shared vision on circular construction




This is the thinking behind a new collaboration between Realdania and Laudes Foundation.




The two funders bring different tools to the transition. Realdania funds research and the development of new circular products and works on the demand side through building clients, procurement, and demonstration. Laudes works with their partners across Europe to inform policy, investment, and markets, with a focus on ensuring that the transition also works for and is shaped by the people and communities affected by it.




Realdania Circular Construction 2.0 works with established Danish manufacturers of concrete, insulation, bricks, and wood to scale take-back schemes. The Circular Buildings Coalition, which Laudes initiated, works across Europe on financing models, return schemes and market demonstrations.




The intention is that the two initiatives feed into one another rather than operate side by side.




What Danish manufacturers learn about the practical barriers to take-back and reuse can be shared with companies and public actors in other European markets through the Coalition. At the same time, the Coalition’s work elsewhere can inform what is tested in Denmark.




In London, for example, ReLondon is developing a demonstrator to standardise pre-demolition audits and build the data infrastructure needed to make information about reusable materials easier to aggregate, share and act on at scale. That experience can inform demonstration projects in Denmark, while lessons from Danish manufacturers can help identify what information companies actually need if reuse is to become commercially viable.




What other funders can learn from this




There are three lessons other climate funders can take from this approach.




First, funders do not need to do everything themselves.




Some foundations are strong in policy, others in research, others in market development or demonstration. Their efforts can go much further when those capabilities are deliberately combined rather than funded side by side.




Second, funders need to be willing to work with companies.




In my dialogue with funders, and in some funding criteria, I have for various reasons seen a tendency to keep commercial organisations at arm’s length. I think that risks overlooking how change actually happens in an established industry.




Companies take real risks when they invest in sustainable transitions before market demand, regulation, and the business case are clear. Once a business case is proven, however, commercial finance is central to taking solutions to scale. The opportunity for philanthropy lies in helping to create the conditions that allow that investment to follow. Working with industry does not have to mean transferring philanthropic money directly to individual companies. It means understanding where companies are getting stuck and asking which of those barriers can be solved for the market.




That leads to the third lesson: philanthropy can be particularly valuable when it funds shared market infrastructure.




Changing an established industry requires resources no single company can build alone: agreed methods for documenting reused materials, ways to check their quality and performance, reliable information about what is available, and better knowledge of what buyers need. That might mean, for example, developing methods for documenting reused bricks, creating data standards for materials identified before demolition, or testing business models that connect the supply and demand for reclaimed components.




Philanthropy can fund that work. And this is where different forms of funding can work together: philanthropic and public funding can help build the evidence, infrastructure and market conditions that are difficult to finance commercially, while private capital can invest in the solutions once they are ready to scale.




Climate philanthropy has an untapped opportunity in construction: to help de-risk the early stages of market development where individual companies, public authorities and investors cannot act alone; to build the infrastructure that allows new markets to function; and to give policymakers the evidence they need to raise requirements once solutions have been shown to work.




So, my ask to other funders is simple: what is preventing manufactures, architects, contractors, and public buyers from doing this at scale? And which of those barriers affects the whole market rather than just one company?




This is where philanthropy may be able to make its biggest contribution.




Simone Kongsbak is Partner at Smith Innovation / Smith Commons.




Disclosure: Smith runs programmes funded by Realdania and Laudes Foundation, including both initiatives described in this article. Smith Innovation is a Copenhagen-based innovation consultancy supporting planetary transition within the built environment and Smith Commons is a not-for-profit entity affiliated with Smith Innovation whose focus is on running innovation programmes for foundations.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *