FanDuel exec says single Luis Ortiz pitch first triggered inquiry in pitch-rigging case


BROOKLYN, New York — A FanDuel Sports executive testified Monday that a series of bets made on pitches thrown by Cleveland Guardians pitcher Luis Ortiz were what initially triggered the suspension of numerous accounts, just days before the Cleveland Guardians pitcher was placed on administrative leave. Ortiz’s Guardians teammate, Emmanuel Clase, was placed on leave several weeks later.

The testimony from Josh Mehta, who oversees legal and regulatory affairs for the sports betting platform, was the first concrete evidence indicating what likely triggered the investigation into the alleged pitch-rigging scheme that has led to four federal charges each for Ortiz and Clase.

Six bets were placed on FanDuel on one specific Ortiz pitch on June 27, 2025, netting more than $19,000 in profits. The pitch in question — the first pitch of the third inning to St. Louis Cardinals catcher Pedro Pages — was a low-and-away slider, resulting in wins for the bettors, who had wagered that the pitch would be a ball.

By the following day, four FanDuel accounts that had placed bets on that pitch, and on a different Ortiz pitch from June 15, 2025, had all been suspended. On July 3, Ortiz was placed on administrative leave. Clase was placed on leave on July 28.

Evidence thus far has shown that bets placed on Clase’s pitches were largely made on DraftKings and ESPN Bet. Executives from both platforms have already testified.

Clase, 28, and Ortiz, 27, have been charged with wire fraud conspiracy, honest services wire fraud conspiracy, conspiracy to influence sports contests by bribery and money laundering conspiracy.

Clase, a three-time All-Star, is alleged to have rigged 18 pitches over three seasons. Ortiz is alleged to have rigged two. They are accused of engaging in the scheme as part of a sports betting conspiracy. A third defendant, Robinson Vasquez, was charged with conspiracy to commit wire fraud. All three have pleaded not guilty and deny the allegations.

Mehta, the FanDuel witness, said he didn’t know specifically why the bets on Ortiz’s pitches were flagged, but said suspensions of accounts typically happen when users violate the terms of use. Mehta also testified that betting with insider information constitutes a violation of the terms of use. He will be cross-examined by defense attorneys on Tuesday morning.

The vast majority of Monday was spent questioning Jenner Olivo, a cooperating prosecution witness, who testified under direct examination that he sent money to a man in the Dominican Republic who used the last name Clase. The man appeared in WhatsApp messages from Enoc Pena’s phone under the name Luis Martinez Clase, but is actually named Luis Gabriel Vargas Martinez, according to prosecutors.

Pena — the man who had allegedly been liaising with Clase and the bettors, in exchange for kickback payments — had directed Olivo to send money to this man, who was not further identified. Olivo said he didn’t know who the man was, but that he ultimately sent three payments totaling $5,500 in April 2025.

Under questioning from prosecutor Rebecca Urquiola, Olivo also further contextualized a series of text messages the government argues is evidence of Clase’s guilt. Previously, the government showed a screenshot of a text message involving Clase from Sept. 30, 2023, in which he instructs Pena that “It’s chicken number three. After killing the first two, play number three. And if I can’t kill him, don’t play. I have to kill the first two.”

On Monday, Urquiola showed Olivo messages of Pena further questioning Clase about insider information from the same text thread. Then she showed group text messages from Pena that included Olivo, in which he reports to the bettors to play the first pitch of the third batter. Clase ultimately didn’t pitch in that game.

On cross-examination, the three defense attorneys all filled different roles in their line of questioning.

Clase’s attorney, Michael Ferrara, asked Olivo if he’d ever had any direct contact with Clase regarding betting, which Olivo said he hadn’t. He also attempted to discredit the evidence related to Luis Martinez Clase receiving payments from Olivo. Ferrara established through questioning that Pena owns roosters and gambles on cockfighting in the Dominican Republic, which could have been a reason Pena instructed the funds to be sent.

Ferrara also established that many of Olivo’s bets lost, and showed Olivo several of Clase’s other pitches against the same batters as the allegedly rigged pitches, portraying Clase’s pitch selection as a part of a predictable pattern which Pena could have studied.

Ortiz’s attorney, Elizabeth Geddes, challenged Olivo by noting his participation in separate schemes to assist Pena, and another man identified only as El Vale, in acquiring fraudulent bank loans and debit cards. The government has said it’s unlikely to call Pena as a witness, despite offering him a cooperation agreement.

“He’s a person that gambles constantly,” Olivo said of Pena.

Under cross-examination from the defense attorney representing Robinson Vasquez, Olivo said that Vasquez had nothing to do with the scheme. Olivo said he’d told the government that before his testimony.

Olivo and Vasquez used to live together as laborers on the island of Nantucket, in Massachusetts. Vasquez ran a “san,” which is a form of community savings that is popular in the Dominican Republic, and Vasquez’s attorney, Todd Spodek, has argued through questioning that payments related to the alleged conspiracy are actually from the san.

Spodek said after court that he’s planning to file an acquittal motion after the government rests its case, citing a lack of evidence against his client.

The government said it hopes to rest its case by the end of the day on Friday, though it could extend until early next week. On Tuesday, the parties are expecting a key ruling from a United States appeals court on whether or not text message evidence between Ortiz and his spouse can be admitted. It is not currently known what the messages say.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *